Differential Depletion of Mg and Fe in Planetary Nebulae: Implications for the Composition of AGB-Star Dust
Abstract
We have investigated the gas-phase abundances of Mg and Fe, both refractory elements that are potentially major constituents of silicates and other minerals, for 25 planetary nebulae. The Mg abundances are derived from Mg II 4481 A, a recombination line of Mg++; we obtain Fe/H from [Fe III] 4658 A, after correcting for ionization structure. We find strikingly different behavior for the two elements. Fe is deficient by factors of 20-200 relative to solar, presumably due to incorporation into dust that condensed while the star was on the Asymptotic Giant Branch (AGB). On the other hand, Mg/H is virtually solar, implying that Mg is at most minimally depleted. This result is surprising since some of the nebulae display mid-infrared emission features often attributed to forsterite, the pure-Mg form of crystalline olivine. If this identification is correct, there must be only a small mass of Mg-rich crystalline silicate dust, coexisting with a larger amount of Fe-rich amorphous silicates or another Fe-bearing material. Another possibility is that the observed features might actually arise from Fe-rich crystalline silicates such as fayalite, which provide a good fit to the spectra of some AGB stars (Pitman et al. 2010, MNRAS, 406, 460; Guha Nigoya et al. 2011, ApJ, 733, 93). Finally, our Mg abundances are based on an optical recombination line (ORL), and such lines from C, N, O, Ne tend to be anomalously strong in nebulae. Although empirically Mg does not correlate with the ORL abundance discrepancy (Barlow et al. 2003, ASPC, 209, 273; Wang & Liu 2007, MNRAS, 381, 669), solving the origin of the ORL effect would increase our confidence in our Mg/H values. This work was supported by NSF grants AST-0708245 to HLD and CAREER AST-0642991 to AKS, and Big XII Faculty Fellowships to both.
- Publication:
-
American Astronomical Society Meeting Abstracts #219
- Pub Date:
- January 2012
- Bibcode:
- 2012AAS...21934301D