Time Periods of Unusual Density Behavior Observed by GRACE and CHAMP

Time periods of low cross correlation between precision orbit ephemeris (POE) derived density and accelerometer density for CHAMP and GRACE are examined. In particular, the cross correlation for GRACE dropped from typical values near 0.9 to much lower values and then returned to typical over the time period of late October to late December of 2005. This time period includes a maneuver where GRACE-A and GRACE-B swapped positions. However, the drop in cross correlation begins and reaches its low point before the maneuvers begin. In addition, the densities were found using GRACE-A, but GRACE-B did most of the maneuvering. The time period is characterized by high frequency variations in accelerometer density of the same magnitude as the daylight to eclipse variations over the course of an orbit. However, the daylight to eclipse variations are particularly small during this time period because the orbit plane is near the terminator. Additionally, the difference between the accelerometer and POE derived densities are not unusually large during this time period. This implies the variations are not unusual, just more significant when the orbit plane is near terminator. Cyclical variations in correlation of the POE derived densities with accelerometer derived densities are seen for both GRACE and CHAMP, but the magnitude of the variations are much larger for GRACE, possibly because of the higher altitude of GRACE. The cycles seem to be phased so that low correlations occur with low beta angle when the orbit plane is near the terminator. The low correlation is possibly caused by the lower amplitude of the daylight to eclipse signal making higher frequency variations relatively more important. However, another possible explanation is terminator waves in density that propagate to the thermosphere from lower in the atmosphere. These waves have been observed in CHAMP accelerometer data and global circulation model simulations. Further investigation is needed to see if the variations correspond to terminator waves or if they represent typical high frequency signal from another source that is more apparent when the orbit plane is near the terminator. 1. C. A. McLaughlin, E. Fattig, D. Mysore Krishna, and P. M. Mehta, "Time Periods of Anomalous Density for GRACE and CHAMP," AAS/AIAA Astrodynamics Specialists Conference, AAS 11-613, Girdwood, AK, August 2011. 2. C. A. McLaughlin, A. Hiatt, and T. Lechtenberg, "Calibrating Precision Orbit Derived Total Density," Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets, Vol. 48, No. 1, January-February 2011, pp. 166-174.