The relationship between plutonism and volcanism: zircon ages from granitoid clasts in recent pyroclastic deposits from Tarawera volcano

In Quaternary magmatic systems that have not undergone extensive uplift that would expose their intrusive roots, co-magmatic (and xenolithic) plutonic clasts entrained in eruptive deposits are an important source of information on the temporal relationship between plutonism and volcanism. Granitoid clasts in pyroclastic deposits of the 0.7 ka (Kaharoa) eruption from the Tarawera volcano of the Okataina Volcanic Centre (OVC), New Zealand, provide a rare insight to the plutonic processes beneath one of the most productive Quaternary rhyolite centers on Earth. SIMS U-Th and U-Pb data on 79 granitoid zircon crystals from six clasts reveal a unimodal age spectrum yielding a weighted average model age of 211 ± 4 ka (MSWD = 1.1). This crystallization event coincides with relative quiescence in OVC volcanism. A few outlier antecrysts date back to ~700 ka, a period significantly longer than the known volcanic record at OVC (probably ~330 ka). In contrast, zircon crystallization in co-erupted pumice and lava of the 0.7 ka Kaharoa event, and that of the three preceding rhyolite eruptions, occurred mostly during 0-50 ka. Thus, the granitoid clasts represent part of the system immediately beneath the volcano that survived assimilation and/or destruction in subsequent eruption and caldera collapse episodes. Brittle deformation features, incipient alteration and low-d18O whole-rock compositions (+3%) are consistent with a shallow solid carapace that has interacted with hydrothermal fluids. However, d18O SIMS analyses of zircons (+5.4 ± 0.2 %; n = 11) are consistent with magmatic compositions, and thus meteoric interaction occurred post-emplacement. The Kaharoa granitoids contrast with those ejected in the ~60 ka caldera-forming Rotoiti event, that were partly molten and display zircon age spectra indistinguishable from that in co-erupted pumices, suggesting the latter were derived from contemporaneous crystal mush. The 0.7 ka Kaharoa case shows that, over time, eruptible parts of a magmatic reservoir can become armored by a solidified intrusive carapace that minimizes interaction with other parts of the magmatic system and the surrounding wall-rocks. Thus, plutonic and volcanic evolution can diverge even in close proximity of the same magmatic system.