The Isotopic Record of Elevation Thresholds in Continental Plateaus to Atmospheric Circulation

High-elevation orogenic plateaus and mountain ranges exert a strong control on global climate and precipitation patterns and interact with lithospheric and upper mantle tectonic processes as well as atmospheric circulation. Reconstructing the history of surface elevation thus not only provides a critical link between erosional and tectonic processes but also ties Earth surface processes to the long-term climate history of our planet. This interaction, however, has important implications when using stable isotopes (O, H) as proxies for landscape and terrestrial climate evolution as interacting land surface properties (elevation, relief, vegetation cover) and atmospheric circulation patterns (upstream moisture path) may attain threshold conditions that can cloak or amplify the impact of topography on isotopes in precipitation. A large number of stable isotope studies in lacustrine and pedogenic environments of intermontane basins record the isotopic and sedimentologic fingerprint of the evolving landscape of the Cenozoic western North American Cordillera. In general we observe the onset of strong oxygen isotope in precipitation gradients along the eastward and westward flanks of the Cordilleran orogen and associated ¹⁸O-depleted moisture within the Cordilleran hinterland to develop no later than 50-55 Ma in British Columbia and Washington, 49 Ma in Montana, and 39-40 Ma in Nevada. However, some of these shifts to very low oxygen isotope compositions in meteoric water occur at rates that by far exceed those that could be attributed to tectonic surface uplift alone. Here we present a multi-proxy approach from the Elko Basin (NV) that ties stable and radiogenic tracers of landscape evolution with high resolution Ar-Ar geochronology. In pedogenic and lacustrine deposits of the Elko basin we observe a change in oxygen isotope ratios that is far too large (6-8 %) and rapid (<200 000 a) to be solely due to changes in elevation. Rather we suggest that the combined effects of developing topography and relief and changing global climate conditions during the Mid Eocene climatic optimum interacted to change atmospheric moisture transport. We suggest that such rapid changes in rainfall composition may be relatively common in evolving plateau regions once critical relief and elevation conditions are attained and caution against using stable isotope paleoaltimetry in regions with relatively poor age control where such effects may easily be mistaken as changes in absolute paleoelevation of the plateau region. On the other hand, such highly resolved terrestrial isotope records provide extremely valuable information when trying to recover how landscape evolution interacted with atmospheric moisture transport across the continents and the terrestrial biosphere during times of paleoclimate change.