Copper systematics during mantle melting and crustal differentiation in arcs: implications for S and Pb budgets of the continental crust

During mid-ocean ridge melting, Cu behaves like Sc and is therefore moderately incompatible, as evidenced by the twofold increase in Cu content in MORBs compared to the mantle. However, Cu content in the continental crust is comparable to that of the mantle, implying that during continental crust formation, Cu becomes effectively compatible. Cu is one of the only elements that exhibits Jekyll and Hyde behavior. This switch to being compatible is consistent with the observation that for the majority of arc magmas (as well as MORBs), Cu decreases with increasing SiO2 and decreasing MgO. Using natural samples, we infer new partition coefficients that indicate Cu is incompatible in olivine, pyroxenes, amphiboles, and biotite. The only mineral to exert significant control on Cu partitioning is sulfide. Cu behaves incompatibly during mantle melting because the modal abundance of sulfides relative to silicate minerals is extremely low. The monotonic decrease in Cu in most differentiating arc magmas requires sulfide saturation. In addition, the similar abundances of Cu in many primitive arc magmas compared to MORBs suggests that mantle melting in both environments occurs not only at sulfide saturation but without the need for excess Cu (or S). In a few cases, however, primitive arc magmas begin with high Cu or show increases in Cu with differentiation, which most likely requires unusually high oxygen fugacities in the source or magmatic evolution towards high oxygen fugacity. Such cases may be important for the origin of Cu porphyry deposits, but are generally rare. Because of the close link between Cu and sulfide during magma differentiation, Cu can be used as a proxy for the pre-degassed S content of arc magmas. The S content of continental crust, like many volatile elements, is basically unconstrained, but it can be inferred from Cu, which is much better constrained. Finally, the fact that the continental crust is highly depleted in Cu implies that there is a missing reservoir rich in Cu and by necessity sulfide. Cumulate xenoliths in arc settings fit this persona. Delamination of these cumulates, embedded with sulfides, will have profound implications for the Pb isotopic evolution of the mantle by linking the Pb paradox to continent formation.