Origin of silicic crust by rifting and bimodal plume volcanism in the Afar Depression

The youngest mantle plume province worldwide occurs at the seismically and volcanically active East African - Red Sea - Gulf of Aden (Afar) triple junction, where one or more upwellings has impinged the thick cratonic lithosphere since ~45 Ma. A spectacular example of magmatism in the Afar depression is seen in the present to < 2 Ma old bimodal fissural mafic and peralkaline silicic eruptions in the ~60 km-long Dabbahu-Manda Hararo (DMH) Rift. In this study we report major, trace elements, and Nd-Sr-Pb isotopes in recent basaltic and silicic rocks originating from the center of the DMH rift segment, exposed along the rift axis and flanks of this segment. The rare earth element (REE) patterns of the silicic rocks and basalts are different in two significant ways: (1) the silicic rocks show a prominent positive Ce-anomaly that is extremely rare in volcanic rocks; and (2) this positive Ce-anomaly is accompanied by a strong negative Eu-anomaly. These anomalies are absent in the basaltic rocks. The positive Ce-anomaly is probably due to interaction in a magma chamber, similar in composition to the basalts, with deep saline aquifer or brines that typically show positive Ce-anomaly. The REE patterns of the two lava groups are interpreted to be due to fractional crystallization of plagioclase in a magma chamber similar in REE composition as the basalts that erupted in the DMH segments. We interpret the silicic rocks to be residues after ~20% fractional crystallization of plagioclase in the DMH basalts. The Nd-Pb isotopic composition of the basalts and rhyolites of the DMH are similar to the Ethiopian plume as defined by the ~30 Ma old Ethiopian flood basalts. Based on their high 3He/4He ratios (R/RA ~30) and Nd-Sr-Pb isotopic data, the source of the Ethiopian plume is generally believed to be in the lower mantle. Therefore, the similarity of the Nd-Pb and Pb-Pb isotopic variations between the Ethiopian plume and the DMH lavas indicates that these lavas were sourced from the lower mantle, and this source zone showed little variation over the past 30 Ma. Some of the silicic lavas fall distinctly outside the plume field toward more radiogenic 87Sr/86Sr at relatively restricted Nd and Pb isotopic compositions. This excursion in Sr-isotopic ratios of the silicic lavas, in concert with their positive Ce-anomaly, is interpreted to be due to mixing of the Afar plume derived basaltic magma with fluids from saline aquifers. We conclude that the bimodal lavas are consanguineous, the silicic lavas being generated by fractional crystallization of plagioclase in a lower mantle plume-derived basaltic magma-chamber, caused by the interaction with saline aquifers. The generation of bimodal volcanism from parental primitive basalts without any contribution from pre-existing continental crust in Dabbahu may explain other similar intraplate magmatism including early Archean-Hadean continental crust formation prior to onset of arc-volcanism.