Geochemical Differences between two adjacent streams in the Tenaya Lake region of Yosemite National Park

Tenaya and Murphy Creeks are two small, intermittent streams with drainage basins adjacent to each other in the Tenaya Lake region of Yosemite National Park. Tenaya Creek has a drainage basin area of 3.49 km2 ranging in elevation from 2491 to 3012 m; Murphy Creek has a drainage basin size of 7.07 km2 ranging in elevation from 2485 to 2990 m. Both basins are underlain by the Half Dome and Cathedral Peak Granodiorites (Bateman et al, 1983), with chemical compositions that are practically indistinguishable (Bateman et al, 1988). Both streams derive all of their water from snowmelt and rainfall, normally going dry by early August each year. Tenaya Creek flows primarily south-southwest, whereas Murphy Creek predominantly flows south. For nearly all of Tenaya Creek’s length it is bordered by the Tioga Pass Road, the only highway in Yosemite National Park which crosses the Sierras; on the other hand, all of Murphy Creek (except its mouth) is wilderness. During the summers of 2009 and 2010, both creeks were sampled along most of their lengths for major and trace elements. In addition, both streams have been sampled near their mouths periodically during the spring and summer (until they go dry) since 2007. Water discharge has been continuously monitored during this time. Because these streams derive all of their water from snowmelt and rainfall, the water chemistry of each must originate from atmospheric deposition, weathering of the bedrock and/or human or animal inputs. These factors, along with the similarity of the geology, topography and basin orientation, suggest that the water chemistries of the creeks should be similar. Instead, while measured sulfate concentrations in Tenaya and Murphy Creeks are similar in their upper reaches, Tenaya Creek sulfate values are almost double in the lower reaches. No other major or trace element showed a similar pattern, although sodium, potassium, calcium and rubidium showed modest increases. Other concentration differences between the two streams were mostly in magnitude rather than in downstream trends. For example, concentrations of beryllium, cobalt, lithium, niobium, silica and the rare earth elements (REE) were uniformly higher in Tenaya Creek whereas concentrations of iodide, molybdenum, tellurium, and tungsten were higher in Murphy Creek. During each water year, chloride concentrations increase as discharge decreases in both streams, a pattern seen for most elements. In contrast, aluminum, niobium, thorium and the REE decrease with decreasing flow for both streams, indicating that basin export of these is dominated by snowmelt runoff. Although most chemical constituents show similar patterns between drainages over the course of a water year, sulfate is exceptional: concentrations tend to decrease with decreasing flow in Murphy Creek, whereas sulfate increases at a greater rate than does chloride in Tenaya Creek.