A Controllable Earthquake Rupture Experiment on the Homestake Fault

Fault-slip is typically simulated in the laboratory at the cm-to-dm scale. Laboratory results are then up-scaled by orders of magnitude to understand faulting and earthquakes processes. We suggest an experimental approach to reactivate faults in-situ at scales ~10-100 m using thermal techniques and fluid injection to modify in situ stresses and the fault strength to the point where the rock fails. Mines where the modified in-situ stresses are sufficient to drive faulting, present an opportunity to conduct such experiments. During our recent field work in the former Homestake gold mine in the northern Black Hills, South Dakota, we found a large fault present on multiple mine levels. The fault is subparallel to the local foliation in the Poorman formation, a Proterozoic metamorphic rock deformed into regional-scale folds with axes plunging ~40° to the SSE. The fault extends at least 1.5 km along strike and dip, with a center ~1.5 km deep. It strikes ~320-340° N, dips ~45-70° NE, and is recognized by a ~0.3-0.5 m thick distinct gouge that contains crushed host rock and black material that appears to be graphite. Although we could not find clear evidence for fault displacement, secondary features suggest that it is a normal fault. The size and distinct structure of this fault make it a promising target for in-situ experimentation of fault strength, hydrological properties, and slip nucleation processes. Most earthquakes are thought to be the result of unstable slip on existing faults, Activation of the Homestake fault in response to the controlled fluid injection and thermally changing background stresses is likely to be localized on a crack-like patch. Slow patch propagation, moderated by the injection rate and the rate of change of the background stresses, may become unstable, leading to the nucleation of a small earthquake (dynamic) rupture. This controlled instability is intimately related to the dependence of the fault strength on the slip process and has been analyzed for the Homestake fault conditions. Scale analyses indicate that this transition occurs for the nucleation patch size ~1 m. This represents a fundamental limitation for laboratory experiments, where the induced dynamic patch could be tractable, and necessitates larger scale field tests ~10-100 m. The ongoing dewatering is expected to affect displacements in the fault vicinity. This poroelastic effect can be used to better characterize the fault. Nucleation, propagation, and arrest of dynamic fault slip is governed by fluid overpressure source, diffusion, and the magnitude of the background loading in relation to the peak and residual strength in the fault zone at the ambient pore pressure level. More information on in-situ stresses than currently available is required to evaluate the fault state. Yet, initial modeling suggests that a suitable place for such an experiment is where the Homestake fault intersects the 4850-ft mine level or at greater depths.