Fernandina caldera collapse morphology in geometric and dynamic comparison to sandbox models, subsidence sinks over nuclear-explosion cavities, and some other calderas

The 1968 collapse structure of Fernandina caldera (1.5 km3 collapsed) and also the smaller Darwin Bay caldera in Galápagos each closely resembles morphologically the structural zoning of features found in depressions collapsed into nuclear-explosion cavities (“sinks” of Houser, 1969) and in coherent sandbox-collapse models. Coherent collapses characterized by faulting, folding, and organized structure contrast with spalled pit craters (and lab experiments with collapsed powder) where disorganized piles of floor rubble result from tensile failure of the roof. Subsidence in coherent mode, whether in weak sand in the lab, stronger desert alluvium for nuclear-test sinks, or in hard rock for calderas, exhibits consistent morphologic zones. Characteristically in the sandbox and the nuclear-test analogs these include a first-formed central plug that drops along annular reverse faults. This plug and a surrounding inward-tilted or monoclinal ring (hanging wall of the reverse fault) contract as the structure expands outward by normal faulting, wherein peripheral rings of distending material widen the upper part of the structure along inward-dipping normal faults and compress inner zones and help keep them intact. In Fernandina, a region between the monocline and the outer zone of normal faulting is interpreted, by comparison to the analogs, to overlie the deflation margin of an underlying magma chamber. The same zoning pattern is recognized in structures ranging from sandbox subsidence features centimeters across, to Alae lave lake and nuclear-test sinks tens to hundreds of meters across, to Fenandina’s 2x4 km-wide collapse, to Martian calderas tens of kilometers across. Simple dimensional analysis using the height of cliffs as a proxie for material strength implies that the geometric analogs are good dynamic analogs, and validates that the pattern of both reverse and normal faulting that has been reported consistently from sandbox modeling applies widely to calderas.