Persistence and Detectability of Hydrologic Changes Following Multiple Timber Harvest Entries in the Oregon Coast Range: Alsea Revisited

The original Alsea Watershed Study (1959-1973) was a paired study in the Oregon Coast Range designed to assess the physical and biological effects of timber harvesting on water and salmonid resources. The 3 streams chosen for study, Deer Creek, Flynn Creek, and Needle Branch, are tributaries of Drift Creek, which flows into Alsea Bay. The watersheds lie about 16 km from the Pacific Ocean, and have a maritime climate, with mean annual precipitation approximately 250 cm, almost all of which falls as rain from October through March. Flynn Creek served as an undisturbed control watershed, Deer Creek had 3 patch cuts (25% of the watershed area) with a streamside vegetation buffer, and Needle Branch was clearcut (85%) with no streamside buffer. The results of the original Alsea Study showed an increase in annual water yield and 3-day peak flows for Needle Branch, and no significant change for any streamflow metric (annual yield, peak flow, or low flows) on Deer Creek. Because the watersheds "generally appear to be returning to pre-logging conditions" the authors of the original study believed hydrologic recovery had occurred. The streamflow gauging network was reestablished in 1990 as the New Alsea Watershed Study. Additional streamflow monitoring (1990-1996) suggested that the watersheds deemed to be "recovered" still showed departures from the pre-treatment relations. Streamflow monitoring from the same period suggested 24 years for vegetation regrowth to return to hydrologic functions similar to the pretreatment. A literature review of paired watershed studies suggested that in the Pacific Northwest at least 25% of the watershed area needed to be harvested to be detectable with streamflow monitoring. Flynn Creek was designated a long-term Research Natural Area by the USDA Forest Service in 1976, and remains an undisturbed temperate coniferous forested watershed. Deer Creek had a second timber harvesting entry in 1978 of 20 ha and two units of 14.5 and 8.4 ha were logged in 1987 and 1988. Approximately 39% of the watershed has now been harvested. Since the original study, forest management on Needle Branch has included precommercial and commercial thinning. Approximately 25% of the middle third of the watershed was precommercially thinned in 1981. In 1997-1998 approximately 40% of this area was commercially thinned with a 30% basal area removal. With 15 years of additional streamflow data, are the 25% basal area removal and 24 year hydrologic recovery axioms true for the Alsea study watersheds?