The Unreasonable Success of Magnetosphere-Ionosphere Coupling Theory

The description of plasma dynamics on the basis of self-consistent coupling between magnetosphere and ionosphere, as first systematized in the early 1970's, is arguably one of the most successful theories in magnetospheric physics. It accounts for the pattern of magnetospheric convection at auroral and low latitudes, the distribution of Birkeland currents, and the dependence on changing orientation of the interplanetary magnetic field. It can incorporate assumed effects, e.g. of particle sources or conductance variations, to almost any degree of complexity at moderate cost in additional computing effort (compare the levels of physics included in advanced versions of the Rice Convection Model and of global MHD simulations, respectively). Such success combined with relative simplicity, however, is possible only because the theory has limited itself in significant ways. It treats the system in effect as doubly two-dimensional: height-integrated ionosphere plus field-line-integrated magnetosphere, with the background magnetic field structure treated as known or derived from some empirical model. It assumes that the system is always in slowly evolving quasi-equilibrium and deals only with time scales long compared to wave propagation times. Hence the theory is not easily applied where genuine 3D aspects (e.g. height and field-line dependence), poorly known or variable magnetic fields (e.g. open field lines), or transient responses e.g. to rapid solar-wind changes are important, and it is intrinsically incapable of describing explosive non-equilibrium developments such as substorm onset. Possible extensions of the theory, comparison with numerical-simulation approaches, and implications for general space plasma physics (E-J vs. B-V) will be discussed.