X-Ray Crystallographic Studies of Electrostatic Effects in Cubic Insulin

Cubic crystals of bovine insulin were obtained at pH 9 from sodium phosphate buffer. Pathway dependence of crystallization was analysed and crystallization using controlled nucleation was developed. Crystal stability and solubility were surveyed by dialysing the crystals against salt solutions varying in salt composition and ionic strength. Crystals dialysed in 0.1-0.2M Li, Na, K, Rb, NH(4) or Tl salt solutions at pH 9 diffracted to beyond 2.8A, while crystals dialysed in Cs, Mg, Ca or La rapidly lost lattice order. Change in the solvent anion did not affect crystal stability. Electron density maps calculated from X-ray data to 2.8A resolution showed two specific cation binding sites which may be occupied by monovalent cations with ionic radii <1.5A. One site lies between insulin dimers near crystallographic two-fold axis without the close involvement of protein charged groups. Cation binding at this site is important for crystal stability. The other site is alternatively occupied by B10 His in one of its two conformations. At pH 7, the Tl occupancy at both sites was decreased, at pH 9.5 the Tl occupancy of the site near B10 His was increased. The structure was refined using the refined model of cubic porcine insulin and the X-ray data collected to 2A resolution from a bovine insulin crystal at pH 9, to R = 16.1% for the data extending from 10A to 2A. High -resolution data from crystals at pH 7 and pH 10 were collected and analysed. The weights of the two B10 His conformers and the cation occupancy near B10 vary in the pH range from 7 to 10, indicating histidine titration. Shifts in the positions of B1-B4 at pH 7 suggest titration of the B-chain terminal amino groups. Co-operative conformational changes in the surface charged residues A1, A4, B21, B29, B30 at pH 10.2 suggest titration of the A-chain terminal amino groups. In several crystals treated with dichloroethane, the syn-dichloroethane was bound in the niche across the two-fold axis connecting insulin monomers. Dichloroethane binding does not perturb the site geometry and probably leads to cubic insulin preparations of increased stability.