Convection in the vertical midplane of a horizontal cylinder Comparison of two-dimensional approximations with three-dimensional results

Experimental results and numerical data on the flow characteristics of core-driven and boundary-layer-driven regimes (CDRs) and (BLDRs) are compared to two-dimensional solutions for heated convective flow in the vertical midplane of a horizontal cylinder. The data were obtained from laser Doppler velocimetry (LDA) measurements and from three-dimensional numerical solutions. It is shown that the approximate solutions gave the correct Rayleigh-number-dependences and distributions for the velocities in the CDR and BLDR regimes. However, the transition between the CDR and the BLDR, as well as the magnitude of the distribution of velocity components, were found to be dependent on the type of two-dimensional approximation selected. In the case of CDR, core velocities were overestimated by as much as 30 percent by the two-dimensional approximations; and in the case of BLDR, the core velocities were overestimated by 40-50 percent as compared to the measured velocities. A schematic illustration of the flow patterns in the cylinder is provided.