Einstein's Paradox
Abstract
IN his review of Bergson's new book (NATURE, October 14) Prof. Wildon Carr refers to ``Einstein's paradox,'' which he quotes in inverted commas as follows :``Suppose a traveller to be enclosed in a cannonball and projected from the earth with a velocity amounting to a twentythousandth of the velocity of light; suppose him to meet a star and be returned to earth; he will find when he leaves the cannonball that if he has been absent two years, the world in his absence has aged two hundred years.'' It so happens that a paradox of this identical kind was proposed to Einstein himself by M. Painlevé at the Paris conferences in April of this year. Unless I have greatly misunderstood Einstein's reply, as recorded by M. Nordmann in the Revue des Deux Mondes of May 1, this particular paradox, arising from the imaginary departure and return of an observer travelling with great speed from a given point and back again, was shown to be one not legitimately derivable from the restricted theorythe theoretical construction is not one to which the transformation formulæ can properly be applied (PP. 146152).
 Publication:

Nature
 Pub Date:
 November 1922
 DOI:
 10.1038/110668d0
 Bibcode:
 1922Natur.110R.668B